One City

Ordered the book, paid $35, the book was supposed to be signed by McCall Smith and Rankin, No signatures to be found

took this book along with a few other short stories on holiday, and it made ideal holiday reading. i find short stories are good for holidays - just right for a couple of hours on the beach or at the pool. these three are among my favourite authors so a good buy as far as i am concerned.

I bought this book for Irvine Welsh's contribution, but was interested to read the others. I've not read Rankin or McCall Smith before, so didn't know what to expect from them.Overall - it's a good little book for a fairly quick read. I enjoyed all three stories - espcially Welsh's, although I am biased. All fairly unusual tales, with a good mix of style. It's a shame JK Rowling didn't contribute a story - her intro is interesting, but very short.

Fine

Customer service was excellent.The book was for a friend visiting from Croatia.I have read it before and it is acollection of short stories based in Edinburgh.An excellent read.