L.A. Girl Ultimate Intense Stay Auto Eyeliner- Never Ending Blue,Gel

I'm always looking for a good eyeliner for tightlining that won't smudge or get weird on me. My eyes get watery while I'm trying to tightline, which causes whichever eyeliner I'm using to lose pigment, unless I keep swiping a cotton swab across the area, and that really irritates my eyes after a while. I didn't have any of those issues with this LA Girl liner. I'm really impressed with the quality of this thing, especially at this price point. The application process is uncomplicated, the color goes on bold, it stays where it should, it doesn't smudge, and it comes off easily when I wash my face at night. This is basically all I have ever wanted out of a pencil-type eyeliner.

This is great eye liner. Goes on easy and stays all day. Love the color too.

Glides on smooth and lasts all day in the waterline. Both brown shades are beautiful.

Only pencil I've found that stays in my waterline, though it stays a little too well. It's also slightly uncomfortable and I can definitely feel it when I wear it. But it looks nice and stays until I need it to.

This is the best drug store brand eyeliner for the waterline I've ever used, by far. It glides on super easy, and it stays all day long. You have to be careful not to advance the tip out too far or it will break off, because it's very soft, almost like a softened butter consistency.

This is the best black eyeliner I've bought in a very long time and it came recommended by an esthetician. It glides on smoothly, stays all day and even all night, yet removes well with eye makeup remover, and I pray it's never discontinued. Buy it!

This is not a soft color. It is a deep color lipliner. It goes on easy and stays on for hours.

I really wanted to like this pencil. It’s such a pretty & striking shade of blue. I have brown eyes so this blue compliments them beautifully on my waterline. It glides seamlessly without having to tug which causes eye irritation. Also due to its butter texture you never need to sharpen it as it’s retractable. However, even with me setting my waterline with a blue eyeshadow overtop, I still got transfer/raccoon eyes. I wasn’t tearing or rubbing my eyes so this left me disappointed in the results. Not sure if the formula isn’t for me or maybe I need a different technique. But for the price I think it’s worth a try.