MAYBELLINETattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, Blendable, Smudge Resistant, Matte Eyeliner For Up To 36HR Wear, Pitch Black (Smokey Black), Packaging May Vary

This is much better than I had expected! Color quality is deep and goes on easily with a very smooth feel. I primarily use it for my waterline and it takes no work to apply it like many others do. Waterproof and lasts throughout the day, but also comes off easily. Good quality liner and will now be my go-to

This eyeliner does not leave a folded line that is normally seen with older skin. Never thought that was a thing. It glides on so smooth. Definitely recommend.

Second time purchasing. Great product. Thank you. Very gentle on the eyes. Glides on smoothly as well.

Color is A LOT lighter than shown in the images. Not a bad shade, but definitely more of a cool beige tone rather than a light gray.Otherwise, it's a great product. Goes on smooth, builds very nicely with only a few added strokes, and the color lasts all day, even through sweat or rain. Definitely my favorite brand for waterproof liner, just wanted a bit darker of a gray tone.

I use this pencil for my brows and liner. It works great. Color quality, texture , smudge resistance and being waterproof make this a perfect and versatile piece of eyy makeup.

I loved this eyeliner. I ordered more.

I am allergic to the product can't use it

I LOVE this eyeliner. Smooth. Glides on. Easy to apply and it lasts all day. Nice jet black. No color fade. Great item Great price.Believe it’s waterproof because I have to wash it off. I haven’t “tested “ it