docolor Waterproof Eyeliner Pen Super Slim Precise All Day Black Eyeliner Liquid Professional Makeup Liquid Eye Liner Pencil for Women

I was honestly on the verge of giving up on finding a decent eyeliner till I tried this. I had used gel eyeliner for such a long time and eventually got tired of all the little pots drying out and brushes everywhere. I switched to pen liner and like most of the people here, found Physician's Formula to be pretty good. I actually still use the brown Physician's Formula brush pen liner every day, but the black version doesn't work on me for some reason. My eyes always start watering when I wear it, and even though it holds up for a long time under perfect conditions, it definitely won't if your eyes are watery and you're rubbing them the whole night. I finally figured out it was the Physician's Formula liner and switched to this Docolor eyeliner. I almost thought the reviews were too good to be true, especially at such a low price point. I'm here to say that it's true! Look no further. Super dark black, wears like iron, no clogs/flows out well, easy to draw a fine or thick line, very simple to use (honestly doesn't get simpler than a felt tip pen). I had some hesitation that the felt tip would clog after awhile or dry out but I've been using mine for months now and it doesn't look like it's slowing down. If I have any gripes, it's that I wish it had a matte finish instead of glossy, but this is a minor gripe. Also, it would be fantastic if it came in other colors!!

I wanted to write my review after using the Docolor Liquid Eyeliner for at least a Month and I love it! First of all I will give this warning as a newcomer to marker style eyeliner. There is a learning Curve that is NOT the fault of the Product but user experience. I was new to perfecting the wings and marker liner so it took me a few weeks to feel somewhat accomplished(hooded eyes). This Liner stays on which I love. It just sticks and I don't have to deal with reapplying a couple of times a day anymore. At fist your lines toward the outside will be too fat but with patience and practice and lots of youtube help you will master it. The other added bonus is this Product not only has long lasting staying power it also can be removed easily! I had also bought this product from Amazon , S & T Always Off Makeup Remover Cloths. These Micro-Fiber Makeup Cloths are basically uber soft little wash cloths that remove makeup easily. Things like eyeliner and mascara come off in a snap and I encourage everyone to give micro-fiber remover cloths a try. There are many brands on Amazon to choose from. I digress due to my being highly pleased with two Products that compliment each other. I will be ordering the Docolor Liquid Eyeliner Gel Black again. Quick Warning- I did have a mishap due to my originally using Coconut Oil to remove my makeup. Thought I had thoroughly rinsed my face but there was residue left on my eyes. ANY trace of Oil clogged the Docolor liner. I squeezed the liner tip gently with tissue and wiped off a few times and let it rest for a few days. With a second gentle wipe off on the second day. The eye liner came back to life and is still working like a charm.

This eyeliner glides on smoothly and creates a sharp, precise line without smudging all day. The waterproof formula really holds up, and the slim tip makes it easy to get both subtle and dramatic looks. Overall, it’s reliable and perfect for everyday or special occasions.

I really liked this eyeliner. The color was a dark, subtle green, great for hazel eyes. A green that isn't bright and obvious is hard to find. The tip is fine, making it easy to get exactly the thickness of the lines desired. The eyeliner glides on well. I will definitely buy it again.

I'll be honest - I really wanted to love this eyeliner, so I'm disappointed to report that I didn't. That being said, I didn't hate it...I was just a bit underwhelmed with its staying power. The application was very smooth and opaque which was great, and the fine felt tip allowed for a very precise line which I really liked. I will openly admit that my skills with liquid eyeliners are...lacking. I'm getting better, but it's safe to say that I won't be posting makeup tutorials on YouTube anytime soon. I felt that this eyeliner was very beginner-friendly, and it didn't tug at my lids or skip when I applied it which was very nice. The reason I wasn't completely happy with it was that it definitely wasn't waterproof or sweatproof. The fact that it wasn't waterproof didn't bother me so much because it made it very easy to remove when washing my face. I am out of eye makeup remover, but almost all of it came off with one wash. But I, stupidly, decided to wear it to the first football game of the season, and that's when the real trouble began. I should mention that I have oily skin and oily lids (I've just now discovered that for some reason, the phrase 'oily lids' skeeves me out just a bit), live in Texas, and at this point, I knew it wasn't waterproof. So it's definitely my fault for thinking that I could wear this to a football game. In Texas. During September. Without any issues. It was an 11am game, and I knew we were going to be in direct sunlight in 90-degree weather with about 1000% humidity. Yet for some reason, that morning, I thought to myself, "Should I put eyeliner on today? Sure! I mean, you don't even apply it for work which has AC because you're lazy, but it's definitely perfect for hanging out in Satan's sauna. It'll be fine!" But, it was not fine. It was not fine at all. Within 15 minutes, my sweat teamed up with the eyeliner and my mascara, and the three of them ganged up on my poor defenseless eyeballs. Let me tell you, the "irritable melted raccoon on meth" look is not a flattering one. So yeah, in summary, I don't love it, but I don't hate it either. I'm not sure why mine wasn't waterproof when the ones received by other customers very obviously were waterproof (check out Evonne N's review for a pictorial demonstration of how the eyeliner supposed to hold up against water). I'm not sure if I received a knockoff version or not, but I know that had the eyeliner I received actually been waterproof, I would have left 5 stars.

This is the only eyeliner I’ve found that has a brush tip instead of a felt tip! The brush tip lets you make a much smoother line once you get used to it. Felt tip liners are like markers. This is like a calligraphy brush. The black is darker than my soul and twice as shiny. Tempted to get the other colors but I’d never wear them. Honestly just as good as Stila Stay All Day liquid liner but less than the cost of one of their minis. With as much eyeliner as I use that adds up. I’ve swatched all my “waterproof” black eyeliners on my hand and this and Stila are the only ones that hold up to liquid and friction. I debated leaving this review because I worried the cost will go up if too many people like it but I also don’t want them to stop selling it. The brush tip does take some getting used to if you’ve never used liquid liner but once you do it’s fantastic! Hands down the best I’ve tried in terms of color impact, price and holding up to the Kansas summer heat.

I was excited about getting this eyeliner because currently I use a Stila waterproof liquid eyeliner pen, and I love it. However, it is SO expensive and *sometimes* it is a little TOO waterproof. I love that the Stila eyeliner does not BUDGE while you sleep, and last fall when I had severe allergies and my eyes were watering constantly, I had no issues. Now that it's summer time, I wanted an eyeliner that is just as good but that I wouldn't have trouble washing off before going to bed. WOW. This pen has so many issues. First, I tried to apply it after applying eye shadow. Nope, wouldn't go on. I didn't panic, because I know that when my Stila pen is running low on ink, it doesn't like being applied over eye shadow. So today, I tried applying it on my naked eye. Again, NOPE. It starts to write, and then goes dry, and then STARTS TO WIPE AWAY THE EYELINER YOU'VE ALREADY APPLIED. Literally, it started to look like I took a clean Q-tip to the middle of the drawn line. Second... there is no way it's water proof. I was working on getting it to actually apply to my eyelids for a good 10 minutes, and when I was over it because the ink just wouldn't come out, I took a wet Q-tip and wiped the entire line away. Just like that. Gone. Like it was never there. The style and design of the pen is great - I love the felt tip eyeliners. And the price was GREAT considering the $22 I pay for a Stila pen. But this eyeliner is absolutely useless and I would return it if I could, on principal, even though it was a measly six bucks. Save your money (and the time it takes to reach you, since it isn't a prime product) and try another brand.

So I'll be the first to admit, I'm not a makeup pro by any means. I'm absolutely terrible with pencils and gel is too finicky for me. This eyeliner pen has been an absolute lifesaver. It goes on smoothly, evenly, and best of all, easily. It creates a lovely cat's eye look, or just a regular application. I tried both the Nyx and Kat Von D's eyeliner pens and wasn't nearly as happy as I am with the Docolor. I find it a far more consistent application than either of the other two. I've never had any issue with waterproofing or rubbing making it come off or look bad, and find that it looks nearly as good when I take it off at the end of the day as when I first put it on. I've just reordered for the 4th(?) time, and I don't think I'll be making a change anytime soon. I will note that they changed the lettering to gold from purple on the package now (recent packaging change) but it seems to be the same otherwise. Highly recommend, especially if you've struggled with other pens in the past. This was a game changer for me!