Nikka NottoLiquid Eyeliner Waterproof Set of 5 Intense Satin Colors. Black, Brown, Blue, Green & Purple, Stay All Day, Smudge Free, Quick Dry, Smooth Application, Valentine's Gift for Her

This has lots of pigment so the color is strong. I recommend you dip you fingertip in water, blot it and run it along the base of your eyelashes. Than apply the color in a thin or thick line just at the base of the lashes. The water (just barely damp is enough) helps the color run smooth. Once it is on, I pat a little light colored shadow over top using a sponge tip applicator to soften the line. This method will keep the line sharp and clean until you take it off. I have slept in it and the next day it's still strong. (I recommend you remove all eye makeup at night but occasionally you want to look your best, even while you sleep.)Do follow the directions and store with the tip down. If it gets dry, a quick touch in a drop of water and it's good to go again. Nice colors with lots of depth. The brush has a sharp tip if you like a fine line, and can be angled for a thicker one if that's your preference.

I like the range of colors and they last. Purple is my favorite, which is unexpected. I ordered a second set because I didn't want the purple to run out. It hasn't (over 4 months of use). The brown and purple shades, especially the purple, are nice in between shades for those that are fair in complexion, as black can often be too heavy a color. They aren't so dark in color that they look overdone, as so often times is the case. I also have "allergy eyes" - eyes that tear with exposure to allergens such as dust. This eyeliner has stayed put. I'm very happy with the eyeliner and delivery has been quicker than anticipated .

I've had this for a while now and really love it. It's is very easy to apply and sets very quickly. You can make a very thin or very thick line or anything in between. It lasts all day and does require remover to get it off. I bought this specifically for the purple and wear it the most. The other colors are great too. All are pretty dark though. They seem to last as well I wear the purple at least 3-4 times a week and so far no signs of running out.

I LOVE this eyeliner. After coming home to see that my pencil eyeliner had (again!) melted from my upper eyelid down under my lower lashes (how does this happen?) I needed a change. This eyeliner is super easy to apply and it lasts ALL DAY. It may take a bit more work to get it off than my old liners, but it's so worth it. Colors are great - the blue, purple and green are perfectly vibrant without being overly bright. The price is great and the product is great (in my opinion).

Okay so I have used eyeliner pens for years - decades, if I want to reveal my oldness. I have primarily stuck with Stila eyeliner pens, because I could always count on them to 1) Not dry up in a week 2) Have a smaller tip to define wings and 3) they were smudge proof for me.I decided to try these after seeing that I'd get Five for the same price as one Stila pen. I got them, immediately sat down and looked at my new pretty colors, and opted to start with the brown. These pens are comparable, if not better, to the Stila pens in every way. The tips are firm, so they don't get all bendy bendy so it's hard to complete the wing with definition. The colors pop and more importantly - they stay put. In fact, the next morning I still have to use some makeup remover to get the liner off.I will buy these again and again, and the price is SO WORTH IT!

I have hooded eyes so it's very hard for me to find liquid eyeliner that will not smear all over my eyes. However these liquid eyeliners are so perfect. They do not smear at all and stay on all day. The colors are so beautiful and make my eyes look amazing. Worth the buy!

While the colors are lovely, and they are easy to apply, these are definitely not smudge-proof nor waterproof. Since those latter characteristics are why I chose this particular brand over others w/equally vibrant colors, it's really frustrating that they don't live up to their advertising.

These are okay for the price you pay. While one eye goes beautifully, by the time I've moved over to the second (and I'm quick at this) the product applies almost crumbly and dry. It will pull up the color of the previously applied line as well, before it's dry. This is with and without primer.