BestLand 12Pcs Matte Liquid Lipstick + Lip Liner Pens Set, One Step Lips Makeup Sets Pigment Velvety Nude Lip Stain Waterproof Long Wear Lip Gloss Make up Gift Set (Set B)

Color stays all day. Initial application of the lipstick does some sort of odor, which it goes away after a while and you don’t even notice it it’s not something that stays all day. However, the lipstick does and it looks fantastic with the liner. I would like to get a glass one that’s not that, but it looks amazing and I love it. I recommend it.

Mibesposa quedo maravillada con sus labiales

Love the colors but it does not stay for long. Not a lip stair, It easily comes off. It’s not long wear or waterproof. I have to consistently reapply it.

Nice variety of colors. Lip liners are great. The liquid lipsticks do not smell good though. Subtracted a star for the chemical smell.

Love the colors. Easy to use and apply. Does not last all day so make sure you bring it with you.

I threw all of them away. They stunk and I could not put these on my lips.

I love this set! I did not realize that is was both the liner and the lipstick when I first bought it. I had thought I was only purchasing the liner, probably should have read the description better. The liner went on smooth and precise and the matte lipstick lasted a long time. Super happy with the quality of the product for the price. The colors are rich and only take one layer to completely cover the lip. It isn’t sticky and I pretty much forgot I had it on until I looked in the mirror and saw that it had not smudged. I’ve only used two of the colors so far, but I couldn’t be more happy with them.

I just bought this for myself for Mother's Day because I really liked the idea of the lip colors having a specific lip liner that matches each one. I tried to judge the colors as well as I could from a picture. I think, let me say I wish, that every maker and seller of cosmetics understood seasonal color theory, and could describe the make up that people are getting based on those theories. Not only would it lead to a future of few to no wrong make up purchases and save customers money, because customers are happy with what they've bought, companies would get better reviews, and more return customers. Had they done that, I might've known that set B are warm colors. They don't work on me. My daughter can wear them, but my daughter barely ever wears make up. I have two colors in this box that I can somewhat get away with. They are quite dark, and I couldn't wear them during the day. That would be number four and number six. Super disappointing especially since I don't have a go-to manufacturer or seller who I know will sell me only things that will match my coloring. I'm cool summer! With regard to the physical qualities of lipstick, it really is nice to have the matching lip liner and lipstick. It will help you get a nice finished look. You should know that these lipsticks are not only matte, they actually dry on your lips a few minutes after application. You will need lotion, oil, or make up remover to take it off. On the plus side, it won't run, wipe off, or bleed easily. If, however, you already have a problem with dry lips, you'll need a moisturizing primer, and if you want a glossy look, you will need to apply one on top. I think that I was too impressed by the packaging of the lip liners with the lip colors because it's very unlike me not to pay closer attention than I did to where this is made, how it is made, or what is in it. From some of the Q&A's and reviews that I saw after the fact, it looks like perhaps I should have paid closer attention to this. Be a wise shopper, especially when things are going on or into your body. I can't return them, because in order to know if they worked, I had to try each one. Happy Mother's Day to me. 😕

Brilliant vibrant shades.

Nice colours. I like how they feel on my lips. Smooth and lasts. I like the idea of the combo with liner and lip stain. I will be ordering more colours for the price and quality are great!

Although everything else “makeup” that I’ve sourced through Amazon has been good, this one is not. The colours are much more coral than what I expected - and I find the corals to be very aging. The texture of the pencils is such that to get the proper effect, it pulls the skin when applying. Try a different brand.

Good quality...very tinted matte lipstick

Stays on nice lipsticks