Question 1

I have the first and second versions. Is this the new look to the first ? Thanks.

Accepted Answer

If I'm reading this correctly: There have been three main editions of this game in the English language. Sleuth Publications in 1982, Ystari in 2012 and this version by Space Cowboys in 2017. All three have exactly the same 10 cases beginning with case 1: The Munitions Magnate. The difference between them is in translation and presentation. The Sleuth and Ystari versions have numerous spelling and translation errors from the original French which have reportedly been fixed for the Space Cowboys release. The errors were generally easily spotted, but I know it annoyed a lot of customers. This edition also does things like putting the solutions to the cases in envelopes (whereas previously they were almost alongside the questions in the case books) and using a more readable font than the Ystari version.Basically, the Space Cowboys version is the best Consulting Detective has ever looked, but there's no actual new content/cases in it, so if you already own the previous editions, there's no reason to buy this one. Maybe try the Jack the Ripper expansion? That has a few brand new cases and a reprint of the old 80s expansion 'West End Adventures'. If you prefer a more Lovecraftian horror atmosphere, then Mythos Tales uses the same mechanic.

Question 2

Hello, can anyone tell me how many cases there are and what they are called?Thanks!

Accepted Answer

There are ten cases:
1. The Munitions Magnate
2. The Tin Soldier
3. The Mystified Murderess
4. The Lionised Lions
5. The Cryptic Corpse
6. The Mummy’s Curse
7. The Banker’s Quietus
8. The Thames Murders
9. The Solicitors Solicitor
10. The Pilfered Paintings

Question 3

Do you need to have the original consulting detective to play? Is this an expansion?

Accepted Answer

This game re-implements Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective originally published by Ystari. The 10 cases are the same. Sherlock Holmes: Jack the Ripper & West End Adventures is a stand alone game with new cases.

Question 4

Is this a good game for two?

Accepted Answer

Two is the sweet spot.
It's fun solo, but the game really pops once you have someone to sound ideas off as you can get excited about the developments together and share in the experience.
Three players is ok too, but anything more and people start to feel left out and lose interest as the stronger or more confident players will take the lead.

Plays Best at 2
Is still good at 3 or Solo

ASIN	2370990074
Age Range Description	13 years to 18 years
Are Batteries Required	No
Best Sellers Rank	16,732 in Toys & Games ( See Top 100 in Toys & Games ) 506 in Board Games (Toys & Games)
Brand Name	Asmodee
CPSIA Cautionary Statement	Choking Hazard - Small Parts
Colour	Multicolor
Country Of Origin	China
Customer Reviews	4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars (1,874)
Edition	1st Edition
Educational Objective	Develop critical thinking, deduction, and teamwork skills
Estimated Playing Time	90 Minutes
Game Mechanics	cooperative
Genre	Board games
Global Trade Identification Number	09782370990075
Included Components	1x Map of London - 10x Case Booklets - 10x Newspapers - 1x Directory - 1x Rulebook
Indoor Outdoor Usage	Indoor
Is Assembly Required	No
Item Dimensions	6.5 x 23.5 x 31 centimetres
Item Dimensions L x W	6.5L x 23.5W centimetres
Item Highlight	The Thames Murders And Other Cases \| Board Game \| Ages 14+ \| 1-8 Players \| 60-120 Minutes Playing Time
Item Weight	2 Grams
Language	English
Manufacturer	Space Cowboys
Manufacturer Part Number	SHEH03
Manufacturer recommended age	13 - 18 years
Material Type	Paper
Minimum Age Recomendation	14
Model Number	SHEH03
Number of Items	1
Number of Packs	1
Number of Players	1 to 8 Players
Operation Mode	Manual
Set Name	The Thames Murders And Other Cases
Size	The Thames Murders and Other Cases
Special Features	Board Game
Sub Brand	Sherlock Holmes
Subject Character	Sherlock Holmes
Theme	Crime
Unit Count	1.0 count

Asmodee | Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective

Details

Details

Description

Specifications

Common Questions