ILIA - Clean Line Liquid Liner with Precision Tip | Quick Dry, Water Resistant, Smooth Application | Carbon Black-Free, Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free (Classic Black, 0.01 fl oz | 0.55 ml)

I was on the hunt for a cleaner ingredient liquid eyeliner that worked and I finally found this one! It goes on smoothly and stays on! Doesn't smudge- works just as great as my previous eyeliner except with clean ingredients which I appreciate!

I love this brand! I buy Ilia makeup knowing that they don’t put anything harmful to my body in their ingredients. My eyes are super sensitive and I can wear this eyeliner every day!

So very easy to apply without smudging or other mishaps. And phenomenal for sensitive eyes. I have ocular rosacea and can’t wear a lot of eye makeup, and this doesn’t bother my eyes like most of their eyeliners do. Really great quality!

I wanted to love this. I was excited to get this because a lot of companies don't make this product. Sadly, it barely worked. It was supposed to be black and it came out a transparent/gray color. Almost like it was dried up. To get aby color from the tip I had to press hard and even then it barely showed or left a small wipe mark. :(

I love their mascara and this company but their eyeliner was a miss. The felt tip is very sharp, smooth and runs on easily so I was hopeful. But it takes forever to dry and arguably never dries because it sinks and smudges way too easily. Transfers to my top lid and collects in the crease below my eye...not great. The best eyeliner for me is still Anastasia, definitely not non-toxic but holds so well.

It's not as good as other brands, unfortunately. It comes out light.

I use this because it's pretty good for a clean option. It's not as great as the toxic stuff and pretty expensive.

This is my absolute favorite liquid liner, especially for black cat eyes. The tip is very fine, easy to control, and it dispenses the liner smoothly. Quick, easy, perfect!