Light Pink Matte Lip Liner and Dark Lipstick Crayon Set, Velvet Long-Lasting Creamy Lip Liner Smudge-Proof Waterproof High Pigmented Lip Pencil Smooth Longwear Lip Liner For Women Makeup(#02)

Super smooth, lines nicely and perfect color

Very smooth, last long , just what I was looking for. A little pricey. Wish they had a bigger color selection. Would recommend.

The liner was nice and creamy and a great color. Also just a bit darker than the lipstick so that was good . But I didn’t like the lipstick. It was dry snd the color was “z off”. It did not look quite like the photo and was oranges pink. Did it do the trick? Yes. Was the color right? No would I buy agsin? Probably not unless it was to try a different color. Plus because it’s split it’s a lot less product. I wear makeup every day. This is a very petit lip pensil. Not much product. I ran out quick. Not bad. But also not great.

3rd time: CORRECT color! I LOVE It!!

This would probably get a 3.5 for me if we could do that.I like that it has two sides and two widths. That's a nice design element.The pencil end is pretty short on the thicker end. I don't know how long it's going to last with that short of a pencil end.The skinny end broke off easily when I was screwing it up.I had to hold it in to take the picture.It does seem smooth. I've had some hard lip pencils and they aren't fun to use. This is much softer.It's just not quite what I was hoping for.

Butter soft and long lasting. Loved the neutral shade of #2!

The pictured nude color is pretty and brownish, but in person it's more of a bright coral, it looks a little plasticky especially on me with my coloring, so I don't see myself wearing it very much. It's just too bright and too orange. I wish it wore more of a blue/brown so it would be more subdued and therefore nude.That said, it goes on super nicely, it's creamy and blends beautifully, and it stays on and doesn't budge which is nice. It comes off easily with makeup remover, specifically micellar water for me.