Too Faced Killer Liner Waterproof Gel Eyeliner - Black

Not my favorite. The color is fine and it sharpens well, but it always runs down my eyes. Many reviews says it lasts, but I don’t have that same experience. It’s certainly easy to remove with make-up wipes, but I likely wouldn’t purchase again.

It’s a wonderful product. Stays on all day. Love it

I was hoping not to smudge but it did. Overall is okay but I found another brand works better than this one.

Good

I use the black eyeliner, and like that the ingredients are safer than most other eyeliners out there, but unfortunately it doesn't last very long. If I apply it in the morning, by the afternoon the liner has dissolved a bit, leaving only a very thin line. Also, it's not a smooth application, sort of pulls on my eyelid and takes a while to build. Will keep using until I can find another safe alternative.